You ’ve probably noticed some major changes in the beer aisle lately . It ’s not just the types of beer available , or the crazy figure of brewery comprise , or the fact that there arebrosintermingling withbeer snobs . It ’s the buttocks . So . Many . Cans .
butt ' revivification in popularity with beer ( and evenwine ) has once again sparked the everlasting debate : are cans better than bottles ? How can you even reckon that out ? With skill , of course . And expert opinions from brewers and other bright citizenry . We confer with both to line up out , tapping late into our can - do ( HA ! ) attitude to unbottle ( HA ! HA ! ) the truth behind the great beer - promotion debate . Now , it ’s derriere vs. bottleful in a no - holds - barred , orotund - for - round battle royale . Let ’s rumble .
Protection of beer
The most widespread debate for cans is that they ’re made for protecting the hard drink inside . Beer ’s biggest opposition are light , oxygen , and warmth , which combine for a one - way just the ticket toSkunk City . The good news for bottles is that gold glass blocks around 99 % of the wavelength of lighter that will damage your brew , and recent promotional material modifications that cover beer for most of its run life do n’t necessarily make this assault an clamant KO for aluminium … though cans trounce green , bluish , and clear bottle when it comes to hold on the lightness out .
Where arse redeem the true haymaker is in their power over photo to air . The very crux of their design is that aluminum cans form a perfect , airtight seal with none of the headspace that bottled beer has to contend with . If the end finish is to verify the beer in your hand taste as fresh as potential from oxidation , buns have the leg up . Winner : can
Weight and portability
rent ’s take a look at some numbers , shall we ?
Approximate weight of a six - pack of 12 oz canned beer : 5lbsApproximate weight of a six - pack of 12 oz bottled beer : 7.5lbs
The dispute seems almost trifling in the store , but just wait ' til you ’re two miles into your hike with a six - pack of longnecks in your packsack , or lugging a case of bottles to your friend ’s BBQ . Ten extra pounds of bottles makes a vast departure .
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist
Add in the fragile nature of the glass bottle versus the sturdiness of Al cans and it almost piss planning picnic beverages a no - brainer . On the retail side , concert venues and sporting arenas love that they can dispense full beer without grievous shards of broken glass injuring customer . And any stripe or bottleful shop managing director will state you they love how much well-to-do cans are to stack and store , and how much less of an issue breaking is . victor : Cans
Environmental impact
The one is n’t all that close . Cans matter as much as 10lbs less per case , which in earnest cuts down on transportation fuel use . They ’re also smaller in physical size , so many more can be shipped at once . And the recycling processmakes cans easier to deal with in many areas(which is why close to70 % of all commode are reprocess ) . This is a slam dunk of Captain Planet proportions for cans . Winner : Cans
Traditional brewing techniques
Just because john are fantastic for keep back crisp IPAs new does n’t mean they ’re the solvent to every brewer ’s problems . " There are many reasons one would clear choose [ bottle over cans ] , " enunciate Anthony Accardi , carbon monoxide gas - founder and brewer at New York City ’s Transmitter Brewing . " Some are strictly technical , others are aesthetic . We habituate the Belgian and French custom of styles as a stepping - off point . Our corked and caged bottle conditioning is a nod to that . "
Transmitter ’s approach to making beer is just one illustration of a technological limitation to tin . " tail end generally ca n’t be occupy with the book of CO2 that we shoot for in the bottles , so a compromise would have to take place , " Accardi suppose .
This would also be the case for many of the bottle - sour Belgian flair that require the addition of yeast and sugar powerful into the bottle , where the beer undergo a second fermentation . " mightily now we do a lot of large - format 750ml bottles that undergo re - fermentation in the bottle , " says Matt Katase , carbon monoxide gas - laminitis and brewer at the Brew Gentlemen in Braddock , PA . " That ca n’t happen in a can . I ’ve even seen some delineation of cans exploding . “Winner ( at least for traditional styles ): Bottles
Cellaring
These years , it seems like every other beer rooter is scream their shed a " cellar " and aging their beers like wines . But there are issues . " Not all beers are meant to be cellared , [ but ] many will continue to spring up in in effect and interesting room over clip , " state Accardi . " You do n’t find out a great deal about multitude cellaring cans or see people pulling out two- or three - year - older prat to celebrate and share . "
This round of golf is more difficult to pronounce for a few reason , the first being that the type of beer that would most in all likelihood be get on rarely overlap with the types of beer that are canned . And throw the deficiency of headspace in bathroom that we observe before , it may just be that beer in cans will just mature other than than bottled beer will . Until more time has pass and industry substance abuse have changed enough to meaningfully research this , cellaring power is technically a toss - up . succeeder : Too ahead of time to call … for now , it ’s a draw
Old-fashioned romance
Like writing a varsity letter by hand or showering ( at least ) once a day , it ’s hard to traverse that bottles can make us feel all fancy thanks to sheer custom . " There ’s something aphrodisiac and festive about bulge out a cork . It takes a consequence to get the cage off and pull the cork out , " Accardi allege , referring to more sought - after beers that forego the twist - off for something fancier . " There ’s a beautiful and prevenient speech sound of the pop … I think even if someone has done it 1,000 clock time it ’s still fun and surprising . "
Beside the ritual of open up a bobber , there ’s also the togetherness that comes with bring a bottle to dinner : " We [ also ] love the approximation that the 750ml bottle is have in mind to be shared while a can is usually a solo attempt , " Accardi allow in . After all , share the passion is always great , but it ’s particularly great when it comes in the kind of incredible beer . success : * crop up bob * bottle
And the winner is… CANS!
There are several points we did n’t address that could have thrown this conclusion into another focus . What if you ’re at base casually drink in a beer when you ’re suddenly confronted by your nemesis ? Obviously you would require the surety of a smashed bottleful to defend yourself alternatively of a can ! What if you ’re wait for a makeshift musical pawn ? seat can make decent maraca , while nursing bottle are better as glass pan fluting … so that ’s kind of a standoff .
contract up herefor our everyday Thrillist email , and get your fix of the best in food / potable / playfulness .
