" okay , but be back by the bell,“my 12th - grade yearbook advisor would say after he ’d write us pass to exit school grounds when we were n’t technically allow for to . He ’d say we needed to go get guile provision or something .
“ And here ’s three bucks , ” he ’d tote up . “ Get me corn fritter . ”
It would be 2 pm , we ’d have skipped dejeuner , and with empty stomachs and full nitty-gritty , we ’d record hop in the elevator car and chief toRoll - N - Roaster .
Cole Saladino/Thrillist
Unless you live in Sheepshead Bay , Roll - N - Roaster is essentially on the other side of Brooklyn . It ’s a 15 - bit campaign from my old high-pitched schooltime , Edward R. Murrow in Midwood , and an hour and 16 arcminute caravan ride from Williamsburg – the actual other side of Brooklyn . ( That ’s a $ 50 uberX , just to put it into perspective . ) But the gondola drive is one of the best portion – the expectancy building with every red sparkle you hit . In 2009 ( the year we were seniors in high schoolhouse ) , we ’d throw on the radio set and belt Taylor Swift ’s “ Love Story ” at the top of our lungs . new and wild and free … and on a quest for roast beef .
The fact that Roll - N - Roaster is far is likely why you ’ve either never heard of it or have n’t made the trek . But general manager Eric Rodriguez tells me that ’s been changing . While R - N - R started as a position only locals would frequent , it ’s become so much more in the preceding 45 years . “ citizenry come from Downtown Brooklyn . They total from Queens , from Staten Island , New Jersey . They come in from Connecticut , ” he say . “ And now we have multitude from the Bronx that descend and make an society for 30 or 40 sandwiches and take it to their company [ for luncheon ] . ”
Seems like quite the trek for lunch . So why are people journeying that far ? Especially when the Verrazano costs $ 16 ? Ask any buffet car there why they keep come back , and the answer is the same : the nutrient , and the fact that it will forever find like it did four 10 ago .
Cole Saladino/Thrillist
“ It has a hometown tactile sensation , ” says Sheepshead Bay resident David Shapiro , who ’s been eating at Roll - N - Roaster since he was a kid . “ It ’s a neighbourhood - type blank space if you really desire to get a spirit of Brooklyn , and not an up - and - get trendy place . ”
In 1974 , my mom and her friends would also head to Roll - N - Roaster after shoal for roast kick , “ cheez , ” and that “ hometown look ” you probably could n’t opine finding in Brooklyn today ; the thing is , almost nothing has interchange since .
Any local will tell you it ’s a greenhorn mistake to go cheez - less .
Cole Saladino/Thrillist
Bud Lamonica opened Roll - N - Roaster back in 1971 and started serving the now - famous roast beef sandwich : thinly - sliced hot knock beef , onions , and cheez sauce on a pan gravy - dip roll ( now also do as a panini ) . The cheez is , of course , the upright part – pipe - hot , pumped from a value-added tax , and almost sure as shooting not material tall mallow ( not that anyone cares ) . You could get the joint boeuf ( or anything on the card ) without cheez , but why would you ? The slogan at Roll - N - Roaster – “ you may have cheez on anything you pleez ” – is just a trace , but any local will recount you it ’s a greenhorn mistake to go cheez - less .
( I ask one of the cashiers , Alessandra Cappa , how literally citizenry take the Roll - N - Roaster shibboleth . She barely waited a beat before responding : “ Someone once asked us to put cheez in their Coke . ” )
“ People come every twenty-four hour period , ” Rodriguez enunciate . “ They just love it . You do n’t get nauseated of the intellectual nourishment . ”
Cole Saladino/Thrillist
Aside from the cheez , the other reason the great unwashed do n’t get fed up of Roll - N - Roaster is the price . That Brooklyn - famous joint gripe – and the chicken tenders ( my personal favourite ) – come in at just $ 5.95 ; fries - n - cheez are $ 3.45 ( get a cupful of cheez on the side so those golden angels stay crispy ) ; and lemonade and orangeade are $ 2.95 . Nothing on the dementedly extensive menu is more than $ 10 . And if you pool your orders and spend more than $ 35 , you even get a devoid pizza pie .
Victoria , one of my best Quaker since historic period 14 , picks me up the Sunday before Labor Day . We give on a mixed compact disc I made her in high school for the drive over ( we were big into The All American Rejects ) , and attempt to quickly catch up , as it ’s understood there wo n’t be much peach once we get our solid food .
Cole Saladino/Thrillist
It ’s only twelve noon , and you’re able to differentiate from the parking lot that it ’s not too crowded yet . ( Nothing short of a miracle . ) Roll - N - Roaster is a grandiose standalone structure . Its fade orange roof does n’t look weathered or get into , just suggestive of the past . In the window , atomic number 10 signs reading “ knock beef , ” “ roast turkey , ” and “ kid - n - cheez ” invite you in warmly .
And that ’s when you see it ’s bustling . More than a dozen workers are hustling behind the counter already – even though it only opened an hour ago . They ’re shout out monastic order numbers as customers drool with anticipation . “ Babe ! We got a complimentary pizza pie , ” a woman yells to her significant other across the restaurant . Her thick Brooklyn accent makes me homesick . I make a genial musical note to call my mom after . “ You wanna refund on the pizza we ordered ? ” she asks him . He decides that , no , they ’ll just take it home and eat it later . A effective choice .
People are shuffling between the two rooms – one is completely sunlight - drench , and is where I ’ve spent literally hour upon hours of my life ; the other is a little more cave - like , where the registers are located . you’re able to tell apart the newbies easily ; they ’re the ones actually read the menu . My order seldom changes . Sometimes I go for the Western burger or the Western joint beef , which both have Allium cepa band and barbeque sauce on top . Sometimes Victoria get under one’s skin mozzarella stick . Sometimes my other friends get wing . curlicue - N - Roaster is too fussy a place to take your sweet time determine .
" If you come over here , you ’re gon na love it … You ’re gon na keep come back and keep come back . " - Roll - N - Roaster General Manager Eric Rodriguez
All of the interior is old wood , and everything from the tabletops to the gigantic backlit menu to the many signs behind the rejoinder are alter shades of yellow and orangish . There are always balloons near the cashier , and every time you see the word “ please ” it ’s spelled like “ pleez . ” A planetary house below the carte reads , “ We cook to regularise and your wait will be tastefully rewarded , ” which is truthful . While Roll - N - Roaster might be constantly buzz , that does n’t entail your food will go far apace . It ’s fondly get it on as the “ not - so - fast fast - food eating house . ” But that ’s OK , because you ’re wait on calibre . And , my god , you have n’t get joy until you ’ve see them call your number over the mike . “ 864 pleez ! ”
Rodriguez , who ’s been the floor manager for 12 years and the oecumenical director for one , did n’t have it off anything about the restaurant before he set forth working there in 1999 . After moving from the Dominican Republic when he was 18 , he constitute himself passing by Roll - N - Roaster while out with his category . detect the " help wanted " signal in the window , he came by the next week and Lamonica just happened to be outside . He come back the next day , and 17 years later he ’s still there .
If you have n’t figured it out by now , Roll - N - Roaster is n’t the kind of place you up and leave . Or even the piazza you eat at once and never render .
Rodriguez has an commitment to this post and his employee . run into the restaurant through Hurricane Sandy was the proud moment of his career . With the rest period of the staff , they clean up and open in three days because the community needed them . People in the neighborhood had no clean john , no working kitchen , no power , he says . They needed a place to go , and that place was Roll - N - Roaster . Rodriguez tot up that he and Lamonica are always talking about how to improve . “ How can we do things well ? How can we take care of our gang ? ”
One affair remains true always : “ If you total over here , you ’re gon na love it , ” he says . “ You ’re gon na keep coming back and keep coming back . ”
Both Rodriguez and Shapiro hark back to this thought that it ’s all about nostalgia , about always knowing you could come home and find at home . “ It ’s like when you have the food from your female parent , you move away from your house and then you come back home for Thanksgiving , ” Rodriguez says . “ It bring memories for citizenry . ”
One strong memory of my own is from yr ago , when I brought my ex-wife - boyfriend to attempt Roll - N - Roaster for the first fourth dimension – I think I was more nervous than the day he met my family . And another : three years ago , Victoria and I had just finished a repast and The Beatles ’ “ I Want to take Your Hand ” came on over the speakers . After the song finished it started over again . And then again , and then again . The birdsong played on repeat for 45 minutes . It felt like we were in the Twilight Zone , but for some cause we just laughed and stayed put . That ’s the thing about Roll - N - Roaster : you could hear the same song for 45 moment straight and still not want to get up and leave . Honestly , I ’d believably sit through an hour of Nickelback and not wish , so long as I had my comfy prat and knock beef sandwich .
The point is : Roll - N - Roaster imply a lot to a lot of people . If you do n’t have any memories there , you should go make some . It ’s a sliver of New York that remains unchanged in the face of rainbow bagels and Cronuts ® and Ramen Burgers . And that roast beef is damn scrumptious .
Sign up herefor our daily NYC email and be the first to get all the food / drink / fun New York has to offer .
