Rest easy , Evan Peters fans .
Thoughlast night ’s instalment ofReturn to Roanoke : Three Days in Hellended with what looked a gruesome murder , sealed clues – both optic and textual – jot that the actor ’s new character , Rory Monahan , could still be alive . Not necessarily for long , but still . The begin ofAmerican Horror Story ’s sixth time of year included lots ofPeters speculation . His first character , as Edward Phillipe Mott , was … abbreviated . And what , an hour later he ’s supposed to be gone again ? C’m on . Ryan Murphy ’s not that cruel . We hope . Let ’s enquire why Rory might not bedeaddead .
Remember his screen test?
Shortly before his death , Rory took a speech sound call about a CRT screen test for a Brad Pitt movie – one that would require him to leave fructify for an unstated amount of time . Almost immediately thereafter he and his new - ish married woman , Audrey Tindall ( Sarah Paulson ) , made programme to severalise Cheyenne Jackson ’s Sidney theatrical role about the development .
We never saw this happen – but does that intend it never happened ? Ostensibly , we ’re watch found - footage fragments that have been been pieced together by an unspecified manufacturer or editor . Rory told Audrey his agentive role would handle all the logistics , hinting that any hatful - devising and contractual negotiating would occur off - filmdom .
Does Sidney seem like the type of chill guy who would say , " Totally , man , go to LA . fare back when you ’re done " ? No . He ’s originative ! He ’s a dick ! He ’s the type of derange manufacturer who would capitalise on the chance to get panic and controversy right out of the logic gate . It ’d be more like : Sure , you’re able to go , but only if we get to kill you off the show first!And , when stock or a fake remains is found upstairs , what better individual to betray the staged expiry than Saturn Award - succeed actress Audrey Tindall ?
FX Networks
Sound mess up ? Yeah , but also keep in mind Rory ’s the kind of dick who answer the phone by saying , " Herro ! " and who write wedding vows that let in such crinkle as , " Audrey , you are reddish and dreary , you are the color of the Sunday : so bright andhot– so blistering , drab , mom ! " He ’s just as much of an inappropriate , opportunistic hoaxer as Sidney . Not the type to make a insidious issue .
Rory’s death looked like a classichorror-moviedeath
recollect how the slaying blossom out :
Beat by pulsation , the death is almost too cinematic and predictable to be true . It ’s all staged perfectly to either allow for for him to be belt down offReturn to Roanokeearly , or to freak out everyone else in the sign from the get - go . The last two here and now , particularly , represent onscreen like a cheesy leap scare taken straight out of aParanormal ActivityorInsidiousmovie – in the same vein as the one we see Sidney ’s people booby - trapping down in the kitchen .
As for Rory , why would he investigate a serious menace like a home interloper alone and unarmed ? And why wouldeverybodyscream when they see a trace on this showexcepthim ? He dies quietly , alone , out of sight – but on camera . It ’s all so convenient for the actor who needs to leave set ASAP and for the under the weather manufacturer who wants a show that ’s shocking as hell .
FX Networks
Given the sleazeball that Sidney is , viewing audience should question everything they see in the next four episodes – include that crew member ’s gory chainsaw death and Diana ’s car fortuity . Every " real " detail here could be part of Sidney ’s gizmo to air something arresting and arrest even more TV audience thanMy Roanoke Nightmare . ( Do n’t forget : Paulsonhintedthere ’s something of a second turn of events around the corner . )
Will Rory be the lone survivor?
If what that final title circuit card claimed is true – that only oneRoanokeparticipant made it out live – does that mean Rory ’s going to be the lone survivor , because his dying will have been staged and he ’ll have decided not to retrovert from his screen exam ? I ’m disposed to say , firmly no . partially because he ’s contractually obligated , as Audrey take down , to be on the show . Also , that sounds boring as hell . Also , the only survivor slot in all likelihood belongs to one of the real actors , not the re - enactors .
" The next four episodes , we are fancy out , Okay , who ’s the one person who ’s going to make it out alive ? And , What are they live on to do to do payback against a connection that put them all in a situation where they all are pass to be kill ? " MurphytoldE ! on-line last night . " you could not trust [ Matt , Shelby , and Lee ] . What they say and what they explain in their version of [ My Roanoke Nightmare ] is not actually the trueness . "
It ’s tough to say who will elude expiry . Personally , I enjoy the theory that one of the original triplet ’s member ( André Holland , Lily Rabe , and Adina Porter ’s characters ) made a spate to deliver invigorated someone to the literal Butcher . The deduction being everyone else , including Rory , whether last night or down the line , must die .
FX Networks
OK, fine, fine, fine, what if Roryreally isdead now?
We get it . possibly you think the above assembly line of thinking is a reaching .
If Rory ’s really idle , the hyper role player still had the good fortune of dying during the Blood Moon . Meaning , you might get to see his ghost roam the halls of the haunted Roanoke manor house . You also might get to see more of him in flashback – like the meet - cunning - y one act during Audrey ’s first confessional . And– big and – if you ’re in that clique of sticklers that believes his ghost wo n’t reappear because he was n’t kill by the Butcher herself , you might get to see Peters descend back as someone else all . ( Like we say , it would n’t be the first time inAHShistory that one of this saga ’s actors has played multiple role in the same season . )
So do n’t despair . In one form or another , it ’s highly possible you ’ve not see the last of your new favorite ruby-red - headed bro .
FX Networks
Sign up herefor our day-by-day Thrillist email , and get your fix of the best in food / drink / fun .
FX Networks