Our Favorite Girl Scout Cookies, Ranked

Although Girl Scout Cookie season is months by , we ’re quick for our nation ’s good and brightest youthful madam to start selling their baked goods to any American looking to get a merit badge in shamelessly housing a whole box of Thin Mints . particularly because there ’s a raw flavour to try : Raspberry Rally .

We got a sneak peep at what is being call up " Thin Mint ’s babe " and decided to include it in this ranking so you’re able to have your cookie club prepared arrive other 2023 . With the newfangled vying with the old , here are all the Girl Scout Cookies , ranked .

10. Toffee-tastic

There is but a single sleeve of these when you spread out up the tops - slender boxful . It ’s like the Girl Scouts are state , " We know you ’re not going to wish these , or else we would ’ve pack two sleeves in there . " They taste a slight sandy , but sticky pops of toffee are decent .

9. Lemon-Ups/Lemonades

These are practically the same thing — one is shaped like a lemon wheel while the other is inscribed with motivational words . They both have a lemony glaze . Despite being strange - try , these citrus - spiked shortbreads are kind of impossible to stop deplete .

8. Do-si-dos/Peanut Butter Sandwich

Initially , Do - si - dos taste a portion like theLance Toast Chee groundnut butter sandwich crackersthat were popular in my middle school . The aftertaste is a bunch like those Toast Chee crackers too . They ’re lucky I do n’t mind a Toast Chee every now and then . This is a cookie that does n’t taste like a snack - based dessert .

7. Caramel Chocolate Chip

The caramel chocolate fleck rendition offers up a kickshaw that tastes a routine like a granola legal community . It ’s gluten - free , which is a bonus , but unquestionably not the most superior cookie on this list .

6. Adventurefuls

These cookies are described as imp - inspired , which is a little bit misleading based on how dry and crumbly they are . There ’s a dusty cocoa - feeling but not the plenteous fudginess you ’d expect from a elf . If the yellowish brown creme on top was gooey , similar to stickiness that enrobe Samoas , perhaps this cooky would be ranked higher and provide a contrast in texture . or else , the creme is a bit wry as well as one tone — tasting of only sugar , and not the rich depth you ’d require in anything caramel - flavour .

5. Raspberry Rally

I can see why the Girl Scouts of America organization is call this the sister cookie to Thin Mints . It ’s get that flaky , wafer internal and is surface in chocolate . The inside is bright pink and has a hint of unreal boo flavor . Those haunt with Thin Mints might witness it dissatisfactory , but we call back it ’s scrumptious . It would be even good if it had a invigorated raspberry jam interior , though .

4. Trefoils/Shortbread

When else does anyone eat shortbread cookie ? When it ’s Girl Scout Cookie season , and no other clock time . Shortbread is a darling classic , though . It goes with jolly much every red-hot beverage — spicy deep brown , coffee , teatime , matcha lattes . The buttery base is a rattling canvas for so many drink . Let us take a moment to extol the mere creation of this shortbread biscuit , the snack - food version of the Yeti .

3. Thin Mints

The crispiness of this wafer — the Girl Scouts do not call it a cookie on the box , queerly — is the secret to why it ’s so bloody good . Its thinness make you feel like it ’s barely there . It takes a minimal amount of effort for the wafer to yield to your mouth , and within no fourth dimension , a minty sharpness permeates that place where your taste bud live . It only drop off point in time because it denies that it ’s a cooky . And when I buy Girl Scout Cookies , I await to consume cookies . On the other hand , it ’s the best wafer you ’ll ever have in your life .

2. Samoas/Caramel deLites

I hated anything with coconut in it as a small fry — it was like mathematics prep for my taste bud . Now I eat foods educate with coconut palm oil anddrink coconut waterlike I live in Thailand and it ’s punk ( sadly , I do not experience in Bangkok , and it is not cheap ) . But I always loved Samoas . They were the elision to my coconut - free childhood . In adulthood , my love of Samoas has only grown , as they combine dark hot chocolate , toasted coconut , and a cooky with a hole in it . For some reason , the hole adds to the sorcerous timbre of the cooky . It ’s no large than my palm , and yet the Girl Scouts stiff me on themiddleof a cooky ? ! It makes me do it the cookie even more .

1. Tagalongs/Peanut Butter Patties

The Tagalong is not just the good Girl Scout Cookie — it might be the best biscuit ever made . conceive about what give out into a Tagalong : you ’ve get a crispy cookie stratum , a downlike cookie bed , a monkey nut butter layer , and then all of that is underwrite in chocolate . It ’s essentially a Reese ’s with better mouthfeel — and you get 15 of them in one mob !

The Tagalong is a people of feeling and textures that combine to make something in truth corking than the summation of its parts . you’re able to have your Thin Mints and your Samoas and your Trefoils — I wo n’t blame you , they ’re all delicious . But the Tagalong is the great Girl Scout Cookie of all time , and it will carry on to be until coffee and goober pea butter stop being the best feeling combination of all time .

Assorted girl scout cookies on colorful background