Just add pasta for the easiest weeknight dinner.
Saucematters . It ’s the only matter keeping us from eat up naked , tasteless noodles lying in a limp tangle . But show up at the mediocre grocery storage and you ’ll see dozens of options , swan from slop to swank . Some are so scented it feels like you ’re drizzle on tomato sirup , while others are so tasteless you ’re better off sticking with butter . How do you decide which sauce is the one ?
Do n’t occupy , it ’s a science that we ’ve follow to passe-partout . Here ’s how : first , we rounded up a grouping of the country ’s top depot - bought marinara sauces and pick out some recommendations for you . We then pare down a lengthy list of 26 mere marinaras to a few standouts by test them on their own and using them in our own workaday meals . We judged them on aroma , flavor Libra , and coating power . And because blade and tastes shift over clock time , we update this list every class or so to verify the quality and availability still holds up . These jars are our current favorites :
Cucina Antica Garlic Marinara
Price:$7.79From the flavor of it , this marinara seems like some kind of graceful , tomatoes - airlifted - from - Sicily situation . The small jar ’s promotion is countryfied : simulated hand inscription on rough , khaki - color in paper — it ’s all very Nonna ’s house in Italy . Inside the jar , the sauce was sparse and runny but occupy with tomato and onion plant chunks at the same clip , almost like a marinara salsa . Cold , it finished sporty , and with its plenteous spice quotient it could really set off some veal meatballs . But once warm up , the spices tone down and the thorniness take over , making for a very sharp flavour . It ’s best paired with fat marrow to equilibrate that acidity .
Rao’s Marinara Sauce
Price:$7.69Rao ’s is unstoppable . It ’s been a go - to since they hit grocery entrepot shelves , and we ’ve always felt that it tastes like everything a safe pasta sauce should be : velvety but not pureed , robust but not overwhelmingly zest , consistent but never bore . It smell out enticing and clings beautifully to alimentary paste , but the heated sauce reveal a strong umami flavor that master each bite .
The marinara is great , but you ’ve got ta tryRao ’s Arrabbiata . Everything that puts the marinara on this list — the fragrance , the texture , the pasta adhere , the umami — is all here . But the Arrabbiata has a gamy heat that demands mentioning . It ’s not distractingly spicy ; it ’s just picante enough to give your side a glow while you ’re eating it , which kind of make it a beauty product , when you think about it .
Newman’s Own Marinara
Price:$2.99Paul gain a jolly decent product , and this marinara was no elision . It ’s definitely not going to be adrift anyone away , but with its pleasantly thick body , fair finish , and gentle finocchio and St. Basil flavors , it ’ll make your spaghetti 10 - 20 % better than butter and table salt . The only negative , besides a general claptrap - ness , is that the wampum factor grows stronger with heat . I ’m not certain I could rust an integral bowl of the stuff un - doctored , but throw in some piquant pancetta or earthy mushroom cloud , and you ’re in good shape .
Lidia’s Marinara
Price:$7.99Sopped up cold with a chunk of bread , Lidia ’s is top - notch ( seriously , I essentially made everyone in the office try it and the consensus is that it was so dear ) . It tastes as fresh as a bounce garden , with bright St. Basil the Great on the nozzle , diffuse layer of grassy vegetables , and sweet plum tomatoes . But heat completely transmute it in nearly every elbow room . It take on a kitschy quality , losing its pungency and devolving into bitterness . It might be improved by some diced Allium cepa , sea saltiness , or a smattering of briny green olives to cut through the astringency , but on its own it ’s well served as a sink sauce for mozzarella reefer .
Prego Farmers' Market Classic Marinara Sauce
toll : $ 3.99Look , I ’m not one to be swayed by an obvious selling gambit , especially one that aims to beguile bring - your - own - grocery - base eccentric with a stonemason jar - flair container , rustic chocolate-brown paper label and straiten fake stencil inscription .
But damn you , Prego , you wormed your way into my jaded sum . Overlook the exterior and you ’re in for a refreshfully elementary drive that feels more like it came from a legit garden alternatively of an gathering air . It ’s all garlic the right way out the gate , followed by a deep blend of black Madagascar pepper , tomato , basil , and oregano and summed up with a gratifying - n - tangy kicker . The body is on the thicker side , not a great match for a slippery bowl of noodles , but it would be incredible in something that call for a heartier cattle ranch , likelasagnaor thick crustpizza .
The Silver Palate San Marzano Marinara
Price : $ 5.59Thanks to a healthy back breaker of EVOO , the grain of this sauce is wakeful and delicate , broken up by juicy tomato lump and the crunch of the occasional Daucus carota sativa . Cold , it taste o.k. but the vegetable flux with the oil make it more of a gazpacho site — not atrocious , but not wholly appetizing . Heated , however , the Allium sativum comes to life , the chunks moderate and everything mousse brilliantly . Even the pear dressed ore , which sounds kind of gnarly on paper , actually produces a rounded redolence that has us come back for more .
Whole Foods 365 Marinara Pasta Sauce
Price:$2.99This is the sauce of your washed-out dreams . It ’s simple and completely inoffensive in every way , but it ’s also not going to blow your gustatory organ away . It ’s a little oily on top , cling nicely to the noodles , and smells like dead nothing despite the fact that all the herb in the mix still pop on the tongue . It needs no additives on its lonesome , though a few hearty shreds of impertinently grated parm would n’t ache at all .
Trader Giotto’s Traditional Marinara Sauce
Leontyne Price : $ 1.29Trader Joe’ssometimes misses , but this sauce is on pointedness . It ’s hearty with strong , unabashed feel of black common pepper , fennel , oregano , parsley , fresh - track basil , and big hunk of stewed tomatoes that maintain their sleight from start to finish . It smells howling poured over blistering pasta , its sweetness cut with the endearing acidulousness of an aged cabernet . There is no sour aftertaste to be found and it opens up as you carry on to use up it , as if the bowl were a decanter and the sauce a fine vino . It does n’t coat the alimentary paste as steadfastly as we would have skip , but , hey , our friendTrader Joestill makes a hell of a sauce .
Photo by Cole Saladino for Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
Design: Thrillist
