Dick Cantwell calls them " hate tourists,“the beer geeks who started turn up at Elysian Brewing Company ’s original brewpub in Seattle as shortly as the cut-rate sale was announced . " Our service of process staff took it on the Kuki-Chin , " say the 58 - class - old brewer , who co - founded the brewery in 1995 , two decennary before trade it to the existence ’s prominent beer ship’s company , Anheuser - Busch InBev . " mass were buy beer , andliterallydumping them on the flooring , " he says . Then they ’d haunt out the room access and into the urban center ’s Capitol Hill neighborhood in hunting of arealcraft beer from arealcraft brewery . You lie with : a locally owned one thathadn’t"sold out " yet .
It ’s a common thought throughout the industry , as well as with the hopped - up cognoscenti that map as de facto embouchure of the " full beer " movement . After all , the craft motion might have started out as a straightforward pursuance for really damn good beer , but over the year bodied mistrust and contempt for mainstream tastes have become so tightly woven into its indistinguishability that they often seem like defining characteristics .
But like it or not , the groovy craft beer sellout is on . The cunning beer landscape is radically unlike than it was when Cantwell began brew . It ’s changed almost as well between this year and last , whenwe first warn youthat a massive shift was underway . Since then , the number of American trade brewery hasswollento 4,600 , even as craft beer ’s growth is flatten out out . Year - over - class volume was up just 8 % in July 2016 , and will likely remain under double digit for the year – only the third prison term in the past 10 that that ’s happened . That ’s still better thanoverallbeer consumption in the US , which has been slowly give up market ploughshare to wine-colored and spirits since the ' 80s .
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist
For those grounds , and a few more , craftiness brewers across the country have been lining their war chests with institutional capital , or line up themselves under the streamer of Big Beer , look for quick cash to expand , amp up statistical distribution , or just withdraw on . In the past 24 months , " strategical partners " ( i.e. , handsome beer ship’s company ) bought Ballast Point , Elysian , 10 Barrel , Hop Valley , Terrapin , Revolver , Devils Backbone , and Saint Archer outright . Lagunitas sell 50 % to Heineken ; Founders sold 30 % to Mahou San Miguel ; Firestone Walker joined Ommegang and Boulevard under Duvel Moortgat ’s collapsible shelter . Scheol , as this article operate to print , Brooklyn Brewery annunciate it had sold 24.5 % of its company to Kirin , the Japanese bay window .
And , oh , the private equity deals ! Oskar Blues , Full Sail , and others have all sold themselves , in part or in whole , to investment chemical group eager to get in on beer ’s only growing category .
In other Book , shit be happening , compadres . So , we spent the last month question craft brewers , macro purchaser , die - tough drinkers , and diligence analysts to see how , and if , this shift will touch on how we craft beer lovers – you , me , us – will drink . Should acquired brewery like Elysian still count as " slyness , " now that it ’s cast lots with the moneyman ? As lovers of craft beer , must we now reject those breweries ? If the quality story stick high and more people make access to better beer , should we wish ? Does it even matter ?
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist
It does to beer geeks. At least the “loud, sloppy, crying” ones.
In the digital long time , hate tourism hardly requires a physical sojourn to a newly evolve brewery . In August 2016 , on the day Terrapin Beer Company announced it had agreed to be acquired by Tenth and Blake ( MillerCoors ' premium portfolio , through which it bring off its craft learning ) , its Facebook Thomas Nelson Page popped off .
This kind of dissent is easygoing to vent , which might be why you always see and try so much of it upon news of a sales event . " It gets amplify on social media because the great unwashed who have unattackable opinion are a lot louder on the cyberspace than those who are apathetic , " wrote Leah Kuck , Terrapin ’s marketing & communication theory representative , in an email rally with Thrillist . She manages the brewery ’s Facebook pageboy , and was n’t surprised by the reaction .
Brewers – those who ’ve sold , and those who have n’t – tend to agree . " A whole crew of the great unwashed yelling in the wind , " is how John Laffler described a typical online reaction to an learning . The current brewmaster of Chicago ’s independent Off Color Brewing , Laffler built his reputation at Goose Island , but left within a yr of that society ’s sale to ABI . ( " It was just time , " he told theChicago Tribunein a 2012interview . )
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist
But beyond the small , gimcrack cohort of beer geeks who " go on loud , sloppy shout jag each time a brewery is take , " as MarketWatch’sJason Notteput it in a recent email exchange , there ’s a whole mainstream universe of less dogmatical drinker , who really just want some good beer . " The most vocal people are not buying as much aseverybody else,“remarks Laffler . investor are betting that courting everybody else , rather than the pissy minority of beer geeks , is the safe way to sell more beer from their acquired brands .
So far , it ’s working . Partially or fully develop breweries like Lagunitas , Founders , and Ballast Point " are fuck off some of the best ontogeny in craft beer right now , " says Benj Steinman , publisher ofBeer Marketer ’s Insights . Ditto ABI ’s brand name . According to a 2015 Nielsen study commissioned by the Brewers Association , craftsmanship brewing ’s lead advocacy radical , 61 % of workmanship consumer consider a beer maker ’s independence as " reasonably " or " very " important when prefer their beer . But , Steinman says , " the evidence in front of my nose says [ ownership condition ] does n’t weigh " to a mainstream client .
But will it change the beer?
The ink was hardly ironic on Revolver Brewing ’s August 2016 deal with MillerCoors , the country ’s second - largest beer company . The stack , reassign control of the Granbury , Texas brewery to the rural area ’s second - largest beer companionship , had n’t even officially closed yet . But : " It ’s just a pen slash , " Rhett Keisler , a Revolver carbon monoxide - founder , reassure Thrillist on a phone call in early September . " The beer is still the beer . "
( Like many acquired brewery , itwasn’tthe same people at Ballast Point – White exited in the aftermath of the sale , as did the CEO , COO / brewmaster , and CCO . The brewery declined to comment for this story . )
Brewers who have sold systematically deny they ’ve cut any corners . Keisler says the " responsibility is on us " to insure that MillerCoors never foists cost - saving program on Revolver at the disbursal of the quality of its beer . And buyers tend to exact they ’d never ask for such a compromise . " We ’re not touching anything when it comes to the beer , " state Scott Whitley , president of Tenth and Blake , the MillerCoors subordinate that will hold in Revolver .
Jason Hoffman/Thrillist
Still , cautionary tales burst . As the industry ’s large and most strong-growing acquirer , ABI is central to most of them , and as one of its most gamey - visibility purchase in the US , Goose Island has been the conglomerate ’s litmus test . The resultant are mixed .
ABI has expanded production of the sword ’s flagship IPA to its quickness in Colorado , and flat - out moved production of 312 Urban Pale Ale from Chicago ( field code : 312 ) to its facilities in upstate NY . It’stweaked recipesto brew Goose Island ’s hop - forward-moving beers at volume . Onmessage boardsandblogs , drinkers have claimed all this change hurt the beers ' spirit and freshness . This dismay peaked in 2015 , when batches of the coveted Bourbon County Brand Stout were found to be infect with a flavor - ruination , albeit non - toxic , bacterium , and had to be recalled . traditionalist again cried foul and bedevil incrimination on ABI ’s doorstep as " validation " of bad - faith brewing .
Would it have pass if ABI never bought the brand ? Who hump . But it did , and it freak out some the great unwashed out .
But there’s an upside!
Of of course , some change is salutary . Therearesome true welfare to selling that , at least in the brusk term , you ’ll delight as a toper .
consistence is a big top side . Big Beer is renowned for deliver laager that taste exactly the same , no matter where you ’re wassail it . Private equity is famous for having prodigious jalopy of Johnny Cash . Both grant small beer maker easy approach to good equipment and quality - ascendency expertness , which in turn makes it easy to put out batch after batch of identically tasting complex beers at scale .
And ingredients ! " The big gift from ' Uncle InBev , ' " to its acquired breweries , pen Aaron Goldfarb in a Serious Eats storypublishedlast calendar month , " is surely the 1,700 - acre hop farm in northerly Idaho " to which its newly bought breweries have access .
When we call up Felipe Szpigel , the president of The High End ( ABI ’s subtly named premium portfolio ) , he was quick to bring up that same farm , cry Elk Mountain . Take Elysian as an example , he said . " They had this amazing beer called Space Dust , but they could n’t get the hops that they involve . Because of Elk Mountain and the resources we have here , they can start brew Space Dust [ more often ] , and it will become their flagship beer . "
From hops procurement to waste - water treatment ( another unsexy but necessary thoughtfulness that Whitley get up ) , there are facets of the business that main brewers just sorta suck at , and learning can render the people and resource to aid . " A lot of citizenry who start out brewing really do n’t understand business , " says Anat Baron , a former general manager of Mike ’s Hard Lemonade and beer - industry insider who directed 2009 ’s documentaryBeer Wars . A vendee , either with pre - construct infrastructure or the know - how to establish it , can aid newfangled acquisitions get their houses in order so they can " focalise on the beer " ( another plebeian refrain ) .
10 Barrel ’s co - father Jeremy Cox has seen it firsthand . " We were pass a lot of time on [ procurement of ] supply , and poppycock that was n’t all that fun " prior to sell the brewery to ABI in fall 2014 . Now it ’s got more brewers , happier beer maker , and time to innovate on specialism projects , he says , like the Crush tympanum sour programme . Cox and his co - founders claim that the freedoms afford by the acquisition really make 10 Barrel " more craft than before . "
That ’s a issue of endless debate ; your gasoline mileage may deviate . But strike the semantics for a moment , and regard the underlying line of reasoning . Freedom to focalise on brewing , pair with gaoler admission to a pre - existing distribution web ( or , at least , shitloads of money to build one ) , put more full - flavored beer in more places it never was , likestadiums , airports , and chain eating place . Which all sounds pretty groovy , right ?
" Do we expend more - expensive hops and make less money , or do we use less - expensive hops and make more money ? "
The thing about distribution
Here ’s the thing most people do n’t talk about . It ’s just aphrodisiac , and often counterintuitive , but dispersion – known in the industriousness as the " middle grade " because it ’s the legislatively mandated linchpin between brewers and retailer – is " 100 % of the game , " says Baron . " It ’s everything . "
The three - grade scheme is enforce at the state , not the federal , grade , so there are dozens of regional idiosyncrasies . Nationally , here ’s the gist : large brewers do so much business with regional distributors , who in turn do so much business with regional retail accounts , that they havede factocontrol over the three tiers simply due to weighing machine . ( In states where it ’s sound , macros actuallybuydistributorships , formalizing this arrangement . In state where it ’s not , the Department of Justice hasinvestigatedmacros for extend kickbacks and give - for - play arrangements . )
Why does this matter for craftiness beer ? Let ’s say a supermarket mark that its IPA neckcloth is " turn " ( sell ) twice as fast as its other category . No surprise there . The store distinguish the distributor . Let ’s say the distributor is " naughty , " which means that the majority of its business amount from distributing MillerCoors products . Before MillerCoors lined its premium portfolio with hop - forward " craft " acquisitions like Saint Archer and Hop Valley , the distributor would ’ve been forced to either acquit independent brewers ' IPAs to meet the supermarket ’s request , or endangerment missing out on that business concern .
In 2016 , there ’s no need , because now the distributor ( via MillerCoors ) has that family covered with option like Hop Valley ’s Alphadelic or Saint Archer ’s India pale . The retailer is well-chosen , because it has something to trade the client , and the security deposit is bigger than it might have been on an severally produced IPA ( shell ! ) . The distributor is happy because it no longer has to keep meter - consuming relationships with a XII independent breweries , now that it can lean on the portfolio of just one . MillerCoors is felicitous because even though cut-rate sale of adjunct lightheaded lager beer are flag , it ’s selling beer in a increment class .
But what about the drinkers ? Are we well-chosen ?
" A stack of hoi polloi who pop out brewing really do n’t understand business . "
The drinkers are happy! (For the time being.)
The affair is , this is probably as good as it ’s going to get for the category of full - flavored beer . As the food market generate tighter , brewery will break down . There will be few main brewer large enough to contend for the mainstream supermarket shelf space . At the same time , they ’ll struggle to compete with smaller , more nimble guile brewer in on - premise taprooms , and speciality beer legal profession / workshop . " They ’re kinda getting stuff from both sides , " order Steinman .
When those vainglorious - ish regional craftiness brewer start dropping , win breweries will represent memory access to – and define the perception of – bounty " cunning " beer for most of the country ’s drinkers , who are hardly as discriminate as some Dark Lord - hoarder in a basement thumbing through RateBeer . At which point , an acquirer could , theoretically , just sorta make it … less agiotage .
This fear ordinarily comes up when the buyout money is from private fairness , thanks to that industry ’s reputation for slashing price and bail when ontogeny slows , but can put on to strategic mate , too . Independence has allowed craft brewers to put up as a bulwark against a caliber slide , read Jim Koch , co - founder of Sam Adams and chairman of Boston Beer Company . ( Though the company is publicly traded , Koch hold all its ballot share and persist in control . ) " In a very practical sense , " he recount Thrillist , it derive down to a bare question : " Do we use more - expensive hops and make less money , or do we use less - expensive hops and make more money ? "
In a growth marketplace , brewer on all side are able to keep quality high and eke out profits , but as challenger tighten , toll - cutting tactics like substitute cheaper ingredients , discontinue time- and working class - intensive beer , and concentrate production can keep returns high for investor or embodied owners , even as retail prices drop . As Greg Koch , the forthright and fiercely independent co - founder of Stone Brewing , remarks : " The commodity world [ … ] of course , over clock time , reduces choice and quality , and those forces are unassailable , adult male . "
Each acquisition , in other words , is drawing rumbustious craft beer further into the more narrowly defined domain it typeset out to expand . No one – not brewers , analyst , distributors , or drinkers – make love quite where to draw the rail line . At what point does possession status cease to be just a question of semantics ? At what point does it become a threat to quality beer ? And , if expansion is the Francis Scott Key to natural selection , is there a style for craft beer to get while hold back its independence ?
Cantwell does n’t look at the " hatred tourists " as psychopath , he aver . " People in that community were just wounded ; they palpate betrayed and sad . "
Maybe there is!
Up until this point , the conversation has been binary : hard currency vs. craft . Corporate vs. independent . sell out vs. fighting the undecomposed fight . But there may be a viable third way . Greg Koch surely hope so . In June 2016 , heannouncedthe launching of True Craft , a private - fairness - back entity that will take nonage positions in independent craft brewery with a $ 100 million store . " True Craft is behaving in ways that are unlike that traditional private fairness , ” he tells me , explaining that while traditional private - fairness firm are beholden to a timeline to flip out their investments , his will " go on into sempiternity . "
True Craft is just the a la mode ( well - funded , principal brewer - backed ) attempt to forge a craft beer accomplishment Holy Grail : a patient group of private investor , reliable believer who understand the slyness ethos , offering a midway road to beer maker seeking capital to flesh out , or " something more solid than cred " to retire on , as Notte says .
Artisanal Brewing Ventures , which hold both Victory and Southern Tier , is another reflection of this middle agency . Ulysses Management , the secret - fairness firm that backs it , is a " family shop " ( i.e. , the money it manages just come from one or a few flush - ass clans ) , which enables a more farsighted spot than traditional house . " I can hold investments for a foresightful , long time if I think they make sense , " says Paul Barnett , Ulysses ' manage director .
With a CEO from Southern Tier and board seats for both Southern Tier and Victory ’s co - beginner , ABV ( get it ? ! ) hopes to make procurement and distribution more cost - efficacious for both breweries by pooling their clout . " We ’re better place as a combined entity , " says Bill Covaleski , Victory ’s co - founder , noting that together , Victory and Southern Tier represented the 15th - largest trade brewer by volume , as opposed to the twenty-eighth and 31st severally . ( Still , ABV has eight board seats , and Victory ’s beginner only check two of them – a far better prototype than a 100 % buyout , but not one that leaves Covaleski and his cooperator with full control condition , either . )
The most ambitious model of craft beer via media , however , isEquity for Punks USA , a mini - initial public offering / crowdfunding round found byBrewDog , Scotland ’s cultishly popular independent brewery and external gin mill meshing . The investment trust , explained co - founder James Watt , admit US drinkers to corrupt Regulation A percentage of the society ’s US operation , in effect distributing splinter of ownership amongst them . The cheeky prick will open a brewery in Columbus later this year with an unrevealed portion of its $ 50 million target raised . To guard against the temptation to trade – which Watt check Thrillist , and pretty much everyone he ’s ever give an audience to , that he ’ll never do – BrewDog recently ameliorate the caller ’s bylaw to in effect prohibit it . ( " Nailing our color to the motherfucking mast ! " is how itphrasesit . )
Can other craft brewer deploy the BrewDog / Equity for Punks exemplar ? There ’s surely incentive . BrewDog has grown at a freakish rate since being founded in 2007 , include 130 % growth in UK gross sales in 2015 , 44 brewpub internationally , and a cool £ 5.5 million in operating profit ( around $ 7.5 million ) last year . If the ruler is that craft ’s brash , alteration - the - humankind independence just wo n’t work at graduated table , BrewDog is a hell of an exception to it .
That’s all well and good –but what about my feelings?
Dick Cantwell quit Elysian just a few days after his fellow board members decided to sell the brewery . He was the solitary dissenting vote . ( " Dick has been in the stomach of the animal , " state Jim Koch approvingly , upon con that the other brewer would be interviewed for this story . ) Still , Cantwell does n’t think he ’s some kind of slyness brewer submarine sandwich , nor does he reckon the " hatred tourists " as sociopath . " masses in that community of interests were just injure , " he recount Thrillist ruefully . " They felt betray and sad . "
Craft beer has always further an explicitly personal connection between brewers and customers . It ’s asked them to get to hump brewer , put themselves in self-governing breweries , and give a doodly-squat about those brewers ' handiwork . It ’s told them that craft brewers and their customers are , as beer historian Maureen Ogle put it , " noble warriors doing battle against the multitude who want to steal the stool . " It convinced many thatthey are what they drink . So what happens when what they drink changes ?
Craft beer won its battle , but it deliver the goods so handily at first that it ’s having fuss convert anyone that the war still needs to be defend . And if they can retrieve , will many mainstream drinkers still care who actually makes the beer ? " A lot of consumer do n’t , " says Cantwell towards the end of our interview . " That ’s more than they want to think about when they ’re buying a six - pack . "
Sign up herefor our daily Thrillist email , and get your fix of the good in food / boozing / play .
