Captain America : Civil Warhas a caboodle going for it – perhaps too much , since at times it feels like there are several movies within it all vying for the spotlight . But at its best power point , it play up how well - inunct a machine Marvel ’s Cinematic Universe has become . It ’s adequate parts thrilling and emotional , intimate and bombastic . Yet for everything it boom , the flick fails Marvel ’s good onscreen graphic symbol : Natasha Romanoff , aka Black Widow .
The chisel , kindhearted Captain America , the sly Loki , and the ragtagGuardians of the Galaxygroup have all been done DoJ on projection screen , no doubt . But height Marvel is Black Widow , brought to bright life by Scarlett Johansson and given an uphill battle toward popularity . Over a handful of movies , Johansson discover a groove with the character – so much so that fans have also been incredibly vocal about want to see the super - spy extend her own flick . Has n’t come about . The reasons why seem to be , witting or not , by design . Which also makes Black Widow Marvel’sworstcharacter . Believe it , and view this :
Best: She has actual dimension
Superhero morality can often feel as complex as a schoolyard fight . scoundrel want to terminate the world ( or world ) for uncomprehensible reasons ; heroes are full in an uncomplicated path , even if their bodily fluid is sharper and their means a spot more dangerous . fourth dimension has helped the Marvel Heron accrue life moral and backstory , but they are n’t Chekhov characters .
Black Widow ’s strongest trait – layered persona and quicksilver nature – were present in the comics , and thankfully made it into the films . Since her first appearance inIron gentleman 2 , Black Widow has been complex in a way that establish the other grapheme around her seem like composition board cutout . Her backstory – she betrayed the only home and world she ever knew as a Russian / KGB spy – loan her some humanity , and makes her decisions take on a different sharpness .
She ’s a soldier , but she ’s also been a double agent . She ’s brutal , but vulnerable . She often uses men underestimating her to her advantage . She ’s loyal to her friends , but understands that empires may decrease . She ’s a woman who operate on best in the shadows , yet she releases S.H.I.E.L.D. ’s filing cabinet and make the pick to lose her own hugger-mugger identity at the terminal ofCaptain America : Winter Soldierbecause it ’s the correct thing to do . She exists on ever - budge primer , and the role of Black Widow is n’t one she took on voluntarily but rather one she keeps to facilitate the earth , to net the " red in her ledger . " Whenever Black Widow ( and Black Panther , for that matter ) are the focal point inCivil War , the plot is about much more than just brutes duking it out . Their storylines feel like they ’re from dissimilar , more interesting films .
Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
Worst: Who is Black Widow,really?
I often wonder how hoi polloi who have no knowledge of Black Widow in the strip feel about her on screen . Sometimes Black Widow ’s moral complexity make her downright unintelligible and undecipherable . While many classic superhero stories retread the same ground ( Bruce Wayne , I ’m looking at you ) , Black Widow has the precise opposite problem . Despite the many films she has appeared in , we ’ve memorize little on her backstory , or who she truly is . Her heart - to - inwardness with Bruce Banner inAge of Ultrontries to ready - desex the job , but the movie ’s inactiveness does n’t give it any breathing way . Action heroines who are both tough and vulnerable are always nerveless to watch . But the elbow room Joss Whedon treat the forced sterilisation backstory relies on many of the effect he had withBuffy the Vampire Slayer . The account are always propelling forward .
Best: Her friendship with Captain America is legit
Winter Soldiermakes the best usage of Black Widow so far . She ’s demonstrate to be fabulously capable as a fighter and spy . Her allegiances seem to rest on believably shaky ground . And we also get to see her warmth and sense of humor , thanks to her bond certificate with Captain America . There is a entrancing connection between the two , given their different background and moral compasses . It ’s hard for me to pick their best instant inWinter Soldier –Black Widow giving date suggestions after kick Jasper Sitwell off the cap , or when they ’re simply hang out at Sam Wilson ’s place , talk about the fallout around S.H.I.E.L.D.
Out of the total Marvel Cinematic Universe thus far , this is the family relationship I am most eager to see more of . Black Widow and Cap ’s dynamic cave in the celluloid almost as much affectionateness as Captain America ’s friendship with Bucky Barnes / Winter Soldier . It also let us set aside Black Widow , the ex - KGB undercover agent / headline Avenger , to instead get a closer look at Natasha Romanoff , a woman who has hopes , dream , and fears like the rest of us .
Worst: She hasn’t really had much of an arc of her own
Black Widow can be whoever the MCU ’s writers and directors need her to be in a given photographic film , since they have n’t give her a clear arc , which is infuriating for such a fascinating character . InAvengers : Age of Ultron , we see a dream succession of sorts that touches on her backstory in the Red Room , where she was educate to become Black Widow .
Ultron take many of its cues for Black Widow from theRichard K. Morgan miniseries " Homecoming,“especially when introduce the idea of forced sterilisation as essential to assuming the Black Widow identity ( which is an incredibly weighty idea that is n’t done justice at all ) . Of course , Ultrondoesn’t handle her all that well , thanks to the shaky romance she has with Bruce Banner .
Civil Wardoesn’t treat her much better . Her material does have exercising weight : Natasha spend most of the motion picture torn between Captain America and Iron Man , and undergo a variety of heart in the heat of the airport battle . But after let Cap off the hook to go chase the villainous Zemo , she disappears . The third - billed actress , the lightning rod forCivil War ’s interrogative sentence on loyalty and superheroic avail , steps aside so the title heroes can project down – a total missed opportunity . Where was Black Widow in that final competitiveness ?
Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
Best: Her physicality
The action mechanism in superhero epics can often feel so abrupt from the real - world outcome of violence that it does such excellent stage dancing a ill turn . But Black Widow fights with a more awe - inspiring visceral lineament that ’s missing among her more superpowered equal . I ’m not only referring to the fantabulous fight scenes , like the open Nigeria sequence inCaptain America : Civil War , or Black Widow fighting the brainwashed Hawkeye inThe Avengers . Scarlett Johansson has a supreme apprehension of her animalism – alternating between control a elbow room to a more quiet vulnerability – add the part the sort of shapeshifter caliber you ’d carry from someone aim to be a spy .
Worst: Her hair
This may seem like a petty input to make in a conversation about Marvel ’s inability to give a female character enough to do , but hear me out . Black Widow ’s hair’s-breadth changes for every film , and rarely for the respectable . So far , the slick , straight do inCaptain America : Winter Soldiersuited her best . If all the hair changes were aid her to go incognito as a undercover agent , I ’d buy it . The weird Farrah Fawcett - esque coif she sway inCivil Wardoesn’t help her in any way .
The worst interpretation of her pilus ( or at least the one that instantly flummox me ) is how it ’s styled during the hall fight inIron valet 2 . After a an minute of casual glamor , Black Widow ’s hair is suddenly curl within an in of its life . A style like that is n’t nimble , it also looks incredibly fake and perturb . What form of undercover agent has clip for that ? !
Best: She makes Jeremy Renner’s Hawkeye somewhat interesting
Hawkeye may be a spunky , swashbuckling character in the comic strip ( peculiarly thosewritten by Matt Fraction ) , but Jeremy Renner ca n’t muster up much personality in the role ( do n’t get me started about hisBlack Widow thoughtson theAvengers : Age of Ultronpress turn ) . Hawkeye sometimes feels like he does n’t fit into the world he ’s thrust in . That is n’t because he miss the power of many of his peers , but because the various writer and directors adjust the character are never quite certain what to do with him . Hawkeye comes animated in his interaction with Black Widow , which emphasise a history and agreement that seem more nuanced than in their superhero film contemporaries . They ’re actual people , it turn out , just like us , but with half-baked jobs .
Worst: Where is her solo film?
The Marvel Cinematic Universe is almost a X honest-to-goodness . Despite its decisive and financial success , Marvel ’s films still play it safe when it comes to diversity . The fact that we have n’t had any women or masses of color lead these films yet is n’t an oversight ( Black Pantherwill lead off correcting that in 2018 ) . But the deficiency of a Black Widow sidequel is outright ridiculous . 2014’sLucy , which earned a whopping $ 463 million worldwide on a $ 40 million budget , proved Scarlett Johansson is an actress whose name recognition can really sell a moving picture , and she can palm heavy action roles – a rareness for either genderin modern Hollywood . Plus , Black Widow fan have been forthright about demanding to see the character headline her own film . So why has n’t it happened yet ? Marvel is on a path , with moving-picture show line up through 2019 . fit in to the company ’s continue claims , there has n’t been room for Black Widow … yet .
" Black Widow : The Name of the Rose"by Marjorie Liu and Daniel Acuna would be a outstanding inspiration to draw in from . I would kill to see her tense encounter with Lady Bullseye come to the screen ( even though it ’s unlikely that character will make it to the big screenland ) . There ’s no blood shed , no hired gun drawn ; instead , the sequence highlights Black Widow ’s slyness and resolve . With laughable - book movies reaching a zenith in reach , where the entire world must cling in the balance fourth dimension and time again , a Black Widow motion picture could scale down without losing any of the energy .
Marvel Studios head Kevin Feige recentlysaid , " Of the character [ in the serial ] , I would say certainly the one creatively and emotionally that we are most perpetrate to doing [ a solo plastic film for ] is Black Widow . " I ’ll believe it when I see it .
The Avengers (2012) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
Black Widow is complex , dynamic , kick - fanny , and incredibly enchanting . It ’s meter Marvel treats her with the veneration she deserves . Because she ’s the best .
sign up up herefor our daily Thrillist email , and get your fixture of the best in food / potable / fun .
Angelica Jade Bastién is a self-employed critic and essayist establish in Chicago . She ’s indite for Vulture , The New York Times , The Atlantic , Bright Wall / Dark Room , and RogerEbert.com . you’re able to regain her on Twitter:@angelicabastien .
Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
Captain America: Civil War (2016) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures/YouTube
Iron Man 2 (2010) | Marvel Studios/Paramount Pictures
Avengers: Age of Ultron (2015) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
Captain America: Civil War (2016) | Marvel Studios/Walt Disney Pictures
