I grow up 15 miles from New York City , spending my plastic romantic geezerhood in the suburbs that would one daytime be made famous onReal Housewives of New Jersey . After four years of college in Massachusetts , I spend a mostly unmarried half - decade in Manhattan go steady hoi polloi from every borough – but it was n’t until I moved 350 miles away to the absolute middle of nowhere that I found a go out polish rich , more fun , and far more enjoyable than anything Manhattan had to put up .

Redwood is a 600 - person hamlet along a diminutive speck of route 10 miles from the Canadian border in rural New York . This is the " North Country ; " a terminal figure for an outlier region of the state beyond the tundra of Syracuse , Albany , and even Rochester . This label tie a geographic communication channel in the moxie between here and the misnamed " upstate " provinces of places like Westchester and the cultures therein .

North Country is more Alaskan than Manhattanite : the great unwashed here traveling by ATV or hand truck , hunt club and garden their way to full bellies , and feel largely intolerant of annoying downstate legislation like ordnance control .

illustration of small town dating

Jason Hoffman/Thrillist

An uninitiated city girl without ally ( or SO potential ) in this new world , I picked up a two - night - a - hebdomad spear sling $ 2 beer and well drinks to the locals at one of Redwood ’s knock rummy mill . I ’d never tended streak before , and love listening to people ’s stories while pouring them generous shots of clear and bronze pot likker ; tear metal crownwork off Genny Light and Busch bottles ; and dutifully scrawl notes in my newsperson ’s journal behind the taproom .

What I did n’t actualise at the clip was that I ’d just sidled up to a front - row seat to the dating culture of rural America . And I got its lessons , in abundance .

Small towns offer no buffers

In cities , you may jaw 100 unlike bar on 100 different dark and not scarper into any of the same multitude . In five yr in New York City , I ca n’t even name more than one person from any of the apartment buildings I lived in .

But in Redwood , like rural outposts all over the US , I knew about people ’s sexual love hold out before we ’d even been bring in . citizenry in the barroom make out everything about their neighbors ( and neighbors ' neighbors ) . Dating was n’t quiet . multitude come into the stripe a daytime after I ’d been out with someone , and involve how the date was . They made jokes about vehicles spotted in my private road . I ’d bartend while people tell stories ( not all true ) about whomever I was seeing . Exes of people I was interested in , contemn me .

pass five minutes perusing Tinder in Redwood and you ’ll discover your neighbor , a handful of your friends , the guy who painted your theatre , and six people you played pool with at the taproom last Nox . You exchange your location configurations – 30 , 40 , 50 miles away – and still , you recognize these people . The only strangers you ’ll see are military ( Fort Drum is a stone ’s stroke away ) or Canadian ( the mete ’s 15 minutes from here ) .

No buffers = solid background checks

Without anonymity , you know the reputation , date stamp history , and most likely the sexual wellness of all your prospects . Almost everyone you meet , you have intel on . In some direction , that helps narrow down the landing field to people you know are pretty good matches while weed out those you ’d want to bunk from five minute into a date .

A low populace provides a remarkable ego boost

In the almost - decade I ’ve live in the midriff of nowhere , I ’ve been come to on . A lot . 100 of times more than I ’d ever been hit on in the urban center . And it ’s not because of my disarmingly good look – to be at the top of the date food for thought chain requires little more than possessing an unfamiliar brass , different last name , and the occupation of a reasonable weight class .

It ’s because new faces are so grueling to hail by . There was a mystery and allure attached to a individual cleaning woman in her late twenty moving alone to the centre of nowhere . the great unwashed whispered about me ; made up stories about my conquest . Once upon a sentence , when I first moved here after twelvemonth of populate as an anonymous New Yorker , being perceived as this interesting find flattering .

Dating venues are different

Here , citizenry still go out for dinner on their dates . Other popular romantic outings include four - rolling , kayaking , hike , mudding ( do n’t admit it if you do n’t experience what that is ) , sledding ( known to city types as " snowmobiling " ) , motor - in motion picture dramatics , and boating around one of the lakes or river for the daylight . I ’ve never support through a date in the land that mat up remotely airless to the endless reel of consultation - like chocolate date my metropolitan friend drag themselves to .

If you do n’t already be intimate the outdoors , you ’ll learn to – tight . Dates are fun for hoyden . Those high heel I used to jade for a dark out in the metropolis were albatrosses when I had to hoist myself in or out of the full - sized F-150s my dates picked me up in . I have yet to find out a woman up here who turns up her nose at the go of a ride on the back of a Harley or weekend spent camping out at the Watkins Glen racetrack .

The men here are a different breed

There are no metrosexuals here . No lumbersexuals . No hipster , futurist , or any otherinsane fashion trendpopping off on cartridge holder covers . Men have callous hand , camouflage sheets , and gun racks in their living rooms . It ’s not strange to see rakehell in the bed of the truck ; or tackle boxes in the backseat . You ’ll have to press out him to take his ballcap off for dinner ; to wash his hands before … well , anything ; prompt him for the one-thousandth time to clean the dip out of that loving cup in his center console .

These guys can build things , fix anything , and survive for more than three time of day in the wild . They also offer in way I , for one , had never been provided for .

They hold car threshold even though the fomite is n’t fancy ; pay for dinner even if they do n’t have a portion of money ; and give you their gloves even if it ’s -30 out ( yes , it gets that cold here ) . The first couple of times any of the aforementioned things happened , I was stunned . Now , going out with guy rope in other , busier parts of the world where chivalry is lacking , is strange .

Your date is going to see where you live

This whole " I do n’t require my escort to sleep together where I hold up because he / she might be a serial killer " thing just does n’t exist out here . Your engagement is going to find fault you up , or you ’re exit to pick them up – at what is belike their whole entire house , not apartment . You ’ll be invited in . And because there is a two - academic degree interval ( max ! ) for anyone you go out with , you ’re fundamentally vouch to do out of the encounter unscathed .

Cheating is never quiet

ahead of time on in my bartending stint , I met a woman who was carrying on an occasion while her married man was on his concluding deployment abroad . I know this because everyone in town was buzzing about it , whisper about her – and her hubby , and what would happen when he come home . It feel absolutely bizarre to hump so much about the personal animation of someone I barely knew . But I learned rapidly that this was par for the course when you hold out in the middle of nowhere . Everyone just know all kinds of stuff about all kinds of hoi polloi . And what this couple – and so many other estranged couples in the area – go through becomes bonny game for barroom conversation forever .

It ’s prissy to intend having everyone ’s oculus on you would make you more accountable for how you treat people , including your partners . It ’s not always the case .

Relationships never end

Every someone you date , you will see again . In copiousness . They ’ll be at the bank , grocery entrepot , saloon , post office , or convenience store . I ’ve never had a first date here and not heard from the person again . With exes , there will always be weirdness to overcome . And sometimes , yr after things stop , you ’ll get a text or call asking what you ’re up to .

Somehow , exes in the North Country never seem to whole move on .

Dating in the country is nothing like FarmersOnly.com

This is rural America ; not a cartoon . And while it can be tempt to strike all rural - dwelling single are gun - toting Trump enthusiasts with mullet , thing here are apparently more complex than that .

Fed up with the trite left - swiping of Tinder , and curious after multiple city - lie in friends excitedly call the FarmersOnly field to my aid , I queued up the land site and created a profile . But aside from its exaggeratedly old - school website design , goofball nontextual matter , and inferior functionality , it was basically ( and unsurprisingly ) just another crushed - budget dating situation . Also , most people in rural America think it ’s just as derisory a recess dating service as people in the city do . In other words , just anyone ( in this region , at least ) is on it .

People in the North Country just ferment more organically for their family relationship . It ’s significantly easy to meet the great unwashed in person than online in rural America , even with its ludicrously low population .

And somehow , that – even with everyone watching , and knowing , and wondering – is the most refreshing thing of all .

Sign up herefor our everyday Thrillist email , and get your localization of the best in food / drink / fun .