Anyone who ’s had a physical or participated in high school gymnasium year is plausibly familiar with BMI . Those three small letters , which stand for body tidy sum indicant , would have you believe that a unsubdivided math problem is all you need to calculate and rate your overall health .
If this sounds simplistic , it is ! Many experts – including the soul whoinvented it– say BMI fails to fully capture the state of a somebody ’s health . Yet it persists as a go - to indicator of well - being , even though there are more in force , relevant stats that can paint a more accomplished picture show .
What is BMI, exactly?
Body mass index measures a person ’s pinnacle in carnal knowledge to their weight . It ’s account by taking your weight in kg separate by your top in cadence squared . If you ’d favour to keep the math stateside , your BMI is your free weight in pounds multiply by 703 , all divided by your height in column inch square . Whatever number you come out with is your BMI , and if it fall between 18.5 and 24.9 , you ’re normal . Congrats ! Any number below means you ’re scraggy , and above the range stand for you ’re heavy , peradventure even obese .
What weighs more: a pound of muscle or a pound of feathers?
But just because you fall into a range of BMI – underweight , normal , overweight , or obese – does n’t mean that ’s what you indeed are . BMI does n’t recognize that you could be skimpy because of unhealthful behaviors like brainsick diets or illegal means , or even that you might be super marvelous . At the same time , BMI does n’t differentiate between the muscle builder in the gym and the couch potato who have the same height and weight unit . Ultimately , the BMI mark millions of Americans as rotund or underweight , that indeed may not be at all .
" BMI is a great overall measure of a population ’s fleshiness status but it should never be used for an individual , " said Dr. Robert Davidson , theatre director of the Nutrition and Human Performance program at Logan University . " This is because it is overly simplistic as a weight - to - peak proportion and has no prognostic power to prefigure the body composition of an somebody due to the many factors that chip in to body composition , none of which are make by either height or free weight . "
Why does BMI exist if it’s such an ineffective stat?
Even the guy who developed BMI in the first place rear his handwriting with a caution on his good for you mathematics job . Back in the 19th hundred , Belgian statistician Lambert Adolphe Jacques Quetelet ( yikes ! ) create the Quetelet Index of Obesity , which is the current BMI chemical formula but with a way cooler name . Since Quetelet was a mathematician and not a doctor , he said at the meter that the indicant should n’t be used to indicate overall health . Nobody listened , apparently . BMI stuck .
Now , Doctor of the Church have used it to compare patients , while insurance companies have used it to evaluate member .
It turns out that Quetelet may have been right all along , which , again , produce you enquire why no one hear to him . Around54 million Americanswho are categorized as obese or fleshy according to BMI are actually neither , and BMIisn’t the good predictor of cardiovascular disease .
baloon111/Shutterstock
So why doesn’t anyone do anything about it?
Perhaps the most surprising expression of BMI ’s continued prominence is n’t that it ’s a shaky wellness stat – after all , what rule could utterly enchant a person ’s health ? – but that it is so resilient , even when there are estimable tools useable .
Some suggest it ’s a issue of wanton algebra . " I do n’t sleep together why we put so much post in it . mayhap because it was round-eyed to do , " says Dr. Davidson . " Research hoi polloi , people in the fittingness industry have know for a long time that BMI is not a good indicator of health . But , in the medical residential district , once that entropy is in a medical school text , it ’s really unmanageable to exchange it because doctors watch over along with what ’s in the old textbook when they write a new one . "
Many experts say BMI has persisted because it ’s useful for aggregating gravid population , though it does n’t service much use on a per - person level .
designer491/Shutterstock
" [ BMI ] was really made to look at the health of turgid population . It was not designed for person to track their health , " say Dr. Matt Tenneberg at Arcadia Health and Wellness Chiropractic , where he works with professional athletes . " The intellect that it works so well for population written report is because it play most of the time , not all of the meter . The errors in a large population report will eventually regress back to the mean value and the data will be comparatively accurate . On an individual basis , you want the measurement to be as exact as possible . "
So how can I tell if I’m healthy?
Thanks to engineering ( sometimes it ’s good , technology ) , there are better ways to calculate your overall wellness – though it ’s also smart to see a doctor .
Dr. Davidson aver that more accurate measurements that calculate trunk fat ( as opposed to weightiness ) , and whether or not you involve to turn a loss weight , include such Googlable marvel as submersed / hydrostatic deliberation , bioelectrical electric resistance , DXA , MRIs , and theBODPOD . Still , each of these has its drawbacks , as some get with a powerful price tag end and others only focus on fat .
" Every biomarker of health status improves with improve physical fitness and none of them improve with change in body weightiness alone , " Dr. Davidson tot up . " Again , BMI is often used to distinguish a population and name human relationship in a population , but should never be used to assay to predict anything for an mortal . "
Sign up herefor our daily Thrillist email , and get your fix of the good in nutrient / drink / fun .
